To make your creative ideas better you need to agree what better actually is.
And what bad is too.
Creativity’s a very subjective business, one person’s Citizen Kane is another’s Fast & Furious 3: Tokyo Drift.
You need a way to judge work that aligns opinion.
The ‘Creative Ladder’ does that. You’ve probably heard of this, I’m certainly not claiming any credit for it.
I won’t explain it much here other than to say it’s a way of objectively judging work on a scale of 1-10. The best explanation I’ve seen is the Cannes Lions talk ‘Creativity, but Why?’ with Soren Hagh, from Heineken. I’m sure you’ll be able to find this on the World Wide Web.
It’s a brilliant way to not only judge ideas at the concept stage but to track each account’s output, letting you see if it’s better or worse over time. Essential for an agency looking to improve creative.
The point I wanted to make, however, is an error in how I’ve seen it used.
Lots of creatives and agencies score each account the same way, against each other.
Their famous brand accounts making TV ads with big budgets always scoring higher than, for example, B2B accounts that only produce digital banner ads.
You can’t score every account like for like.
Judge each within the bounds of it’s own category.
In the past, I’ve worked on B2B accounts in low interest categories which we scored as highly as our biggest budget, most awarded creative B2C account.
Because the work we were producing was as equally innovative and creative in that category.
And remember, the most important thing is that each account improves over time.
Just like the Fast & Furious franchise (why are we still waiting for Fast XI, come on Vin and The Rock it’s time to make up).